• Culture
    Culture
    Filipino actors Bridgerton

    Get to know the Filipino actors in ‘Bridgerton’

    pura luka vega chappell roan church

    Matched her freak! Pura Luka Vega performs Chappell Roan’s ‘Good Luck, Babe!’ at ‘Church’

    AI and deepfake porn is a form of sexual assault—and we need to talk about it

    AI and deepfake porn is a form of sexual assault—and we need to talk about it

    • Women
    • Queer
    • Politics
    • Environment
    • Food
  • Style
    Style
    Pond's serums

    These night serums are your new solutions for radiant, glowing skin

    5 original Filipino fragrance brands to check out

    5 original Filipino fragrance brands to check out

    Here’s where you can get unique, one-off accessories—designed by you

    • Fashion
    • Beauty
    • Space
    • Shopping
  • Entertainment
    Entertainment
    Filipino actors Bridgerton

    Get to know the Filipino actors in ‘Bridgerton’

    pura luka vega chappell roan church

    Matched her freak! Pura Luka Vega performs Chappell Roan’s ‘Good Luck, Babe!’ at ‘Church’

    charlie’s angels totally spies!

    Our favorite onscreen spies, from Austin Powers to ‘Totally Spies!’

    • Celebrities
    • TV & Movies
    • Music
  • Life+Money
    Life+Money
    Single woman adopts baby

    Forming a family: When a single woman adopts a baby

    painting of baby

    A mother-to-be’s survival guide

    Navigating a friend breakup that has no bad blood

    It’s no one’s fault: When a friendship naturally runs its course

    • Career & Money
    • Parenting & Relationships
    • Sex & Health
    • Astrology
    • Travel
  • Inquirer.net
  • Lifestyle
Reading
It’s time we consider not speaking over diasporic Filipinx
ShareTweet
In Politics
3 min read

It’s time we consider not speaking over diasporic Filipinx

Who are we to invalidate diasporic identities?

By Amrie Cruzon July 26, 2022
preenph filipinx diaspora sdcc
Share

If your reaction to seeing Filipinx trending today is “Oh no, not again,” you’re far from alone because both sides of the fence are tired of the discourse surrounding the word. 

The “inciting” post that a number of people are decrying for using the term “Filipinx” was published by San Diego Comic-Con (SDCC) on July 22. What was supposed to be a celebratory post was met with vitriol rooted in a sense of language purism.

“The Filipinx Voices in Pop Culture was a fun and educational all Filipinx panel discussing Filipinx influences behind your favorite media!” posted SDCC with a photo of the panel consisting of Fil-Am creatives Mitch Narito, Earl Baylon, Law Sharma, and Jason Patrick Galit (JPG). 

The comments section for the post on Twitter and Facebook are filled with angry accusations about how using Filipinx is “insulting,” “virtue-signaling,” “racist,” and worse than being called a slur. Can we please turn the exaggerations down a notch? 

The Filipinx Voices in Pop Culture was a fun and educational all Filipinx panel discussing Filipinx influences behind your favorite media! 📸 Edward S. pic.twitter.com/OOgLFKp2pf

— San Diego Comic-Con (@Comic_Con) July 22, 2022

Luckily, JPG had a level-headed response to the backlash: “Thank you to @Comic_Con for supporting Filipinx creatives in pop culture! But don’t let the comments on the post get us divided! I didn’t want to leave any non-binary or gender-nonconforming Filipinx people out when I submitted this!” he tweeted.

Using a term preferred by a number of gender-nonconforming Filipinx isn’t equivalent to denying that the word Filipino is already gender-neutral. Policing harmless queer terms—like refusing to use a person’s preferred pronouns—is a futile exercise that disregards the fluidity of language and ultimately ends up making some queer folk feel invalidated. If Filipino diaspora and Filipinos who grew up in the Philippines sometimes differ in their approach to self-identity, that’s not a bad thing. 

Just because some terms in Filipino are gender-neutral doesn’t mean the entire language is egalitarian. The Filipino language is also filled with binaries that make gender fluidity a harder concept to understand. Language and culture are intertwined, and creating a more inclusive society means language evolves, too.

Hella Pinay’s nonbinary editor-in-chief Stephanie Gancayco once told us in an interview on Filipinx and decolonization, “I do agree that Filipinx seems to signify that we’re talking about diasporic identity… so I feel like, maybe that is the signal of the diasporic disconnect. Wanting to have language that encompasses diasporic identities is totally OK and valid.”

In the same story, trans scholar and activist Dr. Jaya Jacobo refuted the claim that Filipinx are imposing the use of the term. “From the exchanges I’ve had with diasporic Filipinx, I never had the impression that they were disconnected from the Philippines. In the spirit of dialogue, perhaps we should also ask if we’re willing enough to learn from our diasporic kin, and engage in a conversation with them on this crisis of identity. I also don’t agree that they’re imposing the usage of Filipinx in the Philippines.”

Dr. Jacobo adds that we should be wary of how the Filipinx discourse pulls us away from embracing diversity. “If a Filipina or Filipino refuses the ‘x,’ or if a person in Bontoc or Zamboanga refuses ‘Filipina/o’ altogether, then so be it. One cannot legislate identity. We must remember nationalist discourses have a tendency to deface diversity, just to uphold republican values. ‘Filipina/o’ may not speak to Moro and/or indigenous identities who have historically resisted imperial and republican forms of governance from the peripheries. We should listen to them and learn from their stories of [suffering] and resistivity.”

The next time you see someone use Filipinx, remember that the term is born out of an effort to be more inclusive. Our response to it should be in the similar vein, instead of using it to keep people out of our communities.

 

Art by Ella Lambio

Follow Preen on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, TikTok, YouTube, and Viber

Total
0
Shares
Share 0
Tweet 0
Pin it 0
Share 0

Action Required!

We embed Facebook Comments plugin to allow you to leave comment at our website using your Facebook account. It may collects your IP address, your web browser User Agent, store and retrieve cookies on your browser, embed additional tracking, and monitor your interaction with the commenting interface, including correlating your Facebook account with whatever action you take within the interface (such as “liking” someone’s comment, replying to other comments), if you are logged into Facebook. For more information about how this data may be used, please see Facebook’s data privacy policy: https://www.facebook.com/about/privacy/update.

Accept    Decline

Tags
diasporaFilipinxgender neutralitylanguagequeer

Subscribe to our newsletter

Stay in the loop


By subscribing, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

ShareTweetEmailShare
Amrie Cruz
Amrie is a nonbinary writer who likes to talk about politics and viral animal videos. They have a dog daughter named Cassie who doesn’t go to school.

Peek This

OMNIBUS 2025: A Festival For All

OMNIBUS 2025: A festival for all

Pond's serums

These night serums are your new solutions for radiant, glowing skin

Filipino actors Bridgerton

Get to know the Filipino actors in ‘Bridgerton’

pura luka vega chappell roan church

Matched her freak! Pura Luka Vega performs Chappell Roan’s ‘Good Luck, Babe!’ at ‘Church’

Preen.ph © 2020. Hinge Inquirer Publications, Inc.
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • HOME
  • ARCHIVES
  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • ADVERTISE WITH US
preenph nutritionist dietician jo sebastian diet food
Previous
Why we always deserve to eat, according to nutritionist-dietitian Jo Sebastian
celebrity misinformation criticism ella cruz boy abunda
Next
How do we stop celebrities from spreading misinformation?
  • Culture
    • Women
    • Queer
    • Politics
    • Environment
    • Food
  • Style
    • Fashion
    • Beauty
    • Space
    • Shopping
  • Entertainment
    • Celebrities
    • TV & Movies
    • Music
  • Life+Money
    • Career & Money
    • Parenting & Relationships
    • Sex & Health
    • Astrology
    • Travel
  • Inquirer.net
  • Lifestyle
  • Subscribe
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • Search
Start typing to see results or hit ESC to close
fashion fashion news music Culture News movies
See all results

Subscribe to our newsletter

Stay in the loop


By subscribing, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.