Hold up: Riverdale’s OG Reggie Mantle joins ‘To All The Boys I’ve Loved Before’ sequel

We know you’ve been patiently waiting for any To All The Boys I’ve Loved Before 2 news. You’re probably still reeling from Netflix’s announcement that 24-year-old Rent Live actor Jordan Fisher will star in the sequel of the popular rom-com. Hold on to your hat, ’cause we’ve got another big news for you: Ross Butler, aka Riverdale’s original Reggie Mantle, is joining the cast too!

While Jordan plays John Ambrose McClaren, a recipient of one of Lara Jean Covey’s love letters in the first film (Watch out, Peter Kavinsky!), Ross will play Peter’s BFF, Trevor Pike.

John Ambrose McClaren will be played by @Jordan_Fisher in our “To All The Boys I’ve Loved Before” sequel! pic.twitter.com/0B3KkC6sS3

— Netflix Queue (@netflixqueue) March 28, 2019

Producer Matt Kaplan told Entertainment Weekly, “His real-life friendship with Noah brings a natural chemistry and great rapport to the set and we can’t wait for fans to see this friendship play out onscreen.”

We can’t wait to see it! Dammit, now we don’t know who our fave To All The Boys guy is. Are you having this dilemma too? Let us know in the comments section below.

[The Daily Mail and Vulture]